I disagree.
I've been reading Bringing up Bebe by Pamela Druckerman (read her article in the WSJ here) which talks a lot about the differences in parenting styles of French and American families. I'm only about 1/4 of the way through the book but what she says just makes sense to me. The French are all about teaching their children patience and setting limits. How can we set limits for them if we never tell them "non"? I'm not interested in helping to mold the most creative child in the world - If I can raise the Shrimp to be patient, self-confident, spiritual, charitable, and hard working then I will have done my job. Ok that's a lot of stuff....if I can do half of that then I'll have done my job. If he wants to tell me "no" he can go right ahead and say it all day long. It's annoying but I'm going to do what's best for him whether he likes it or not. This is Mama's house and I will show him that I am in charge in a loving but firm way.
I won't bore you too much more but this book is really great and it makes me feel empowered as a mother. This is Mama's house.
Mama's house.

2 comments:
You're right about not worrying about stunting their creativity--Mom and Dad are in charge and they need to learn to be respectful and obedient. I also know that all our kids are slightly different. Avoiding the "no" word doesn't mean that the "no" concept isn't there strongly. In our case, Ben just knows now that it is not a word he is allowed to use willfully against us without consequences. He can say no to a simple option, and I'll say no too. But a willful NO is something completely different--as in when I tell hm to pick his cheese up off the floor and he might shout NO. That is different from a "would you like a slice of cheese?" kind of no.
Great comment Kathryn - I agree completely. There are definitely different kinds of "no". I really didn't explain the book very well but it's awesome.
Post a Comment